A few years ago, Christopher Hamm was reading up on
monarch butterflies when he noticed something peculiar. All of the scientific
articles that mentioned the number of the insect’s chromosomes—30, it
seemed—referenced a 2004 paper, which in turn cited a 1975 paper.
But when Hamm, then a postdoc at the University
of Kansas in Lawrence, did a genetic analysis of his own, he found that his
monarchs only had 28 chromosomes, suggesting that an error has pervaded the
literature for more than 40 years. Another twist, however, was just around the
corner.
Hamm suspected a mistake when he read the original 1975 paper. The authors,
biologists N. Nageswara Rao and A. S. Murty at Andhra University in
Visakhapatnam, India, had studied what they claimed was an Indian monarch
butterfly in their work. But there’s a problem: Monarchs are nearly exclusively
a North American species. “It’s implied they just went outside their building
and collected some butterflies,” Hamm says. “I immediately thought, ‘Monarch
butterflies in India? Really?’”
Sure monarchs are master travelers, with the longest-known seasonal migration of any insect. And
it’s not uncommon for a few to get blown off course to Australia, the
Philippines, the United Kingdom, and a handful of other places from time to
time. But ending up as far away as India seemed like a stretch. Hamm, now a
data scientist at Monsanto in Woodland, California, also knew that taxonomists
since Carl Linnaeus have struggled to distinguish species in Lepidoptera, the
order of insects to which monarchs belong. For example, the monarch (Danaus
plexippus) and a similar-looking butterfly known as the common
tiger butterfly (D.
genutia) were thought to be the same for more than a century until
they were reclassified as separate species in 1954. And guess what: D.
genutia lives in India.
the same or different butterfly?
christopher hamm study one butterfly that called monarch butterflies but he discovered one mistake, the insect chromosome number 30, it seems referred to the 1975 document.
did his own genetic analysis, he found that his monarchs had only 28 chromosomes, suggesting that an error has permeated the literature for over 40 years.
The authors, of the document of 1875 called N. Nageswara Rao and A. Murty, they studied Indian monarch butterfly but Carl Linnaeus have struggled to distinguish species in Lepidoptera, the order of insects to which monarchs belong.
For example, the monarch and a similar-looking butterfly known as the common tiger butterfly were thought to have been the same for more than a century. And hamm discovered that are different types of monarch butterfly.

